Digging Through the Details
Posted by Smári on August 15, 2013
Over the last 9 days we've been overwhelmed with support for our new project, Mailpile, but also with a lot of questions, suggestions and great ideas for what more to do. We really love all the feedback!
Through these conversations, we've noticed a bunch of technical questions that a lot of people ask, so we've tried to roll them all into a bit of a technical overview.
Warning: The following is kind of geeky.
Just a Mail Client
Mailpile is a Mail User Agent (MUA - commonly called a "mail client") under early development that currently knows how to read mail from Mbox, Maildir and (experimentally) IMAP. There are designs to support POP3 and perhaps other transports. Mailpile is written in Python, and has very few external dependencies that are not packaged with Python's standard library. The most notable of these is GnuPG, which is called from the system path, if it is available.
To unravel that for slightly less technical people, a mail client is the software that lets you view, compose, receive and send mail. It's the thing you see. But on the backend, there are two other types of bits that make e-mail work: Mail Transfer Agents (MTA), which the MUA connect to when they want to send an e-mail to somebody, and relay the messages through the Internet to the recipient, and Mail Delivery Agents (MDA), which manage the final step of getting the e-mail into a user's Inbox.
Still following? Good!
Is Mailpile a Mail Server?
Mailpile is not a Mail Transfer Agent (MTA commonly "mail server" or MDA , Mail Delivery Agent). MTAs and MUAs, are often bundeled together in the case of Gmail. This is kind of important to understand. At the moment, Mailpile is not a mail server (MTA or MDA).
As you can imagine, e-mail does not work if it does not have an MTA or MDA. For now, we're going to rely on traditional e-mail infrastructure, but eventually we may decide to try and have a go at that too. Currently, setting up and maintaining a mail server is painful and difficult- we'd like to fix that too, but not until we've gotten the mail client aspect taken care of first.
The Many APIs of Mailpile
Mailpile's Architectural Differences
There is no external database, but rather Mailpile relies entirely on an internal data structure format. The search index is stored in memory locally, providing quite a lot of speed on searches, which for any term on a modest laptop generally returns well within 0.2 seconds. The search index can be optionally hashed (for instance with SHA256). For further security, the settings folder, including the search index and other configuration items, can be GPG encrypted when it is not in use (Mailpile will handle those details for the user).
Mailpile is different from most MUAs predominantly in that its architectural paradigm is not "list mail from folders", focusing on fetching, listing, viewing, writing and sending mail, with features like search and tagging as an afterthought, but rather a "search engine for mail" with a focus on searching and tagging, with fetching, viewing, writing and sending as necessary but in terms of workflow, secondary actions. This changes a lot of how people interact with mail, and more closely models how most people use e-mail nowadays.
A Killer Combo
This speed, plus the user-friendly interface, means that Mailpile effectively manages to provide the same base functionality as GMail, except that it is free software.
Due to the speed of Mailpile's search engine, it is possible to do various things that generally have not been possible in MUAs before - speed prohibitive - and we're starting to be able to mine for potential functionality that Google has not, such as graphing search results in various ways, making attachment browsers, managing local mailing list groups, and so on.
One thing a lot of people have mentioned to us is providing a different kind of mail transport than traditional SMTP, such as STEED. We'd really like to do that, and we've got some pretty crazy and interesting ideas about where to go with that, but first we've got to get all the other bits working really well.
As you can see, we've got a lot of details down, but there's a lot of work to do. First though, we've got to raise the cash to do the work without starving. Thanks for helping us get there!